Practical online courses: raw materials, plastics processing, recycling and sustainability

The same moulding defect every week: why changing the settings does not remove it

How to find the real cause of short shots, sink marks, warpage and cracks in injection moulding

A defect that disappears after a settings change and returns a week later has not been solved. It has only been moved out of sight.

The scenario is familiar in many injection moulding plants. On the night shift short shots appear on one cavity. The operator raises injection pressure, adds holding pressure and increases the barrel temperature by a few degrees. The parts are good again, production continues, and nobody writes down what was changed or why. A week later the short shots are back, and this time flash has appeared on the parting line as well, because the process is now running at the edge of its window.

When I visit plants as an external expert, my first question is not "which setting did you change?" but "what do you know about the cause?". Very often the honest answer is: nothing. The defect was treated, not diagnosed.

Injection Moulding of Plastics, Part 2: Defect Diagnosis and Troubleshooting, Rolbatch Academy online course

Injection Moulding of Plastics, Part 2: Defect Diagnosis and Troubleshooting, Rolbatch Academy online course

Why changing several settings at once makes things worse

Every setting on the controller affects more than one thing. Higher melt temperature lowers viscosity and helps filling, but it also lengthens cooling time and can degrade the polymer. Higher holding pressure reduces sink marks, but it increases moulded-in stress and can cause flash or sticking in the mould. When three settings are changed at the same time, three effects overlap and nobody can say which one removed the defect.

The consequences build up quietly:

  • the real cause, for example a worn check ring or a new batch of raw material, is still there,
  • the process window becomes narrower, so the next small disturbance causes a different defect,
  • the setting sheet no longer matches what is running on the machine,
  • each shift develops its own way of "fixing" the same problem.

Where defects really come from

In practice the cause of a moulding defect lies in one of four areas. A fixed method starts by asking which area has changed.

Raw material. A new batch with a different melt flow rate, insufficient drying of hygroscopic polymers such as PA, PC, PET or ABS, a higher share of regrind, or recycled material whose properties vary from batch to batch.

Machine. A worn check ring (non-return valve) that lets melt flow back during injection and holding, a failed heater band, unstable hydraulics or a drifting temperature control unit.

Mould. Blocked vents, partly blocked cooling channels, wear on the parting line, or a hot runner zone that does not hold its temperature.

Process settings. A switchover point that no longer suits the shot volume, a holding time that is too short for the gate to freeze, or a mould temperature that differs from the documented value.

Most of this information is already available. The controller records cushion, plasticising time, injection time and peak injection pressure for every cycle. These values are the first place to look, before anyone touches a setting.

A fixed method in five steps

1. Describe the symptom precisely. Not "short shots", but: which part, which cavity, where on the part, since when, on every shot or only on some, on every shift or only at night. A precise description often points to the area on its own.

2. Collect the facts. Controller data from before and after the defect appeared, the raw material batch number, dryer settings and residence time, mould temperature, the share of regrind, and any change in the last few days: a new batch, maintenance, a mould change, a different operator.

3. Form hypotheses. List the possible causes and rank them by how well they fit the facts. If cushion has fallen to zero and varies from shot to shot, the check ring is a stronger candidate than the mould.

4. Test one variable at a time. Change one thing, record the result, and change it back if it did not help. This takes longer than turning several knobs at once, but it is the only way to know what actually works.

5. Set a standard. Write the result into the setting sheet and into a diagnostic card for the part: symptom, cause, action, the value that proved it. The next time the symptom appears, the shift does not start from zero.

What this looks like for typical defects

Short shots. Check the cushion first. A cushion that is zero or unstable points to the check ring or to an insufficient shot volume. A stable cushion with short shots at the end of the flow path points to venting, melt temperature, or a raw material batch with a lower melt flow rate.

Sink marks. These are usually linked to holding pressure and holding time, wall thickness and the moment the gate freezes. The holding time can be set by part weighing: increase the holding time step by step and weigh the parts. When the weight stops increasing, the gate has frozen, and a longer holding time adds nothing but cycle time.

Warpage. Warpage comes from differences in shrinkage across the part: uneven mould temperature between the two halves, cooling channels with different flow, or orientation of fillers and glass fibres. Changing the holding pressure rarely removes it permanently.

Cracks. Cracks can appear long after moulding. Typical causes are moulded-in stress, hydrolysis in PC, PA or PET that were not dried properly, and degraded regrind. Here the investigation often starts at the dryer, not at the machine.

Raw material: the cause that is easiest to overlook

The certificate of analysis says the batch is within specification, so the material is rarely suspected first. Yet a difference in melt flow rate between two batches of the same grade can be enough to move a stable process to the edge of its window. With recycled polypropylene (rPP) these differences are larger and more frequent.

Hygroscopic polymers need drying that matches both the material and the throughput. A dryer chosen for a smaller machine, or a hopper that is too small for the required residence time, delivers material that is only partly dried. Moisture in PC and PET does more than leave streaks on the surface: at processing temperature it breaks polymer chains and reduces the mechanical properties of the part, often without any visible sign.

Safety during diagnosis

Diagnosis means working close to hot moulds, heater bands and moving parts. Before anyone works on the mould, the heaters or the hydraulics, the energy sources have to be isolated and locked out (lockout/tagout, LOTO). A defect solved at the cost of a burn or a crushed hand is not a success.

What changes when the whole team uses the same method

A plant where every shift diagnoses defects in the same way gains three things. Fewer rejects, because the cause is removed rather than masked. A wider and more stable process window, because settings are no longer pushed to the edge. And knowledge that stays in the company, written down in diagnostic cards instead of living only in the head of one experienced setter.

Online courses on injection moulding

At Rolbatch Academy I have prepared two online courses on injection moulding of plastics:

  • Part 1, IM-001: Introduction to the Technology, for operators, junior process engineers and quality control staff. The moulding cycle from the hopper to ejection, the machine and the mould, plastics and drying, holding time by part weighing, cooling time and the cost of a moulded part.
  • Part 2, IM-002: Defect Diagnosis and Troubleshooting, for process engineers, experienced operators and production managers. The five-step method, short shots, flash, streaks, sink marks, warpage and cracks, controller data, processing of recycled material and LOTO.

Both parts are available now in German and Spanish. English, Polish, Italian and Russian versions are in preparation.

How does your plant deal with a defect that keeps coming back: is there one method that every shift follows, or does each shift have its own?

Injection Moulding of Plastics, Part 1: Introduction to the Technology, Rolbatch Academy online course

Injection Moulding of Plastics, Part 1: Introduction to the Technology, Rolbatch Academy online course

About the author

Dr Magdalena Laabs, President of Rolbatch Engineering GmbH and founder of Rolbatch Academy. Expert of the Association of Polish Mechanical Engineers and Technicians SIMP in two specialisations: Materials Engineering (specialisation 109) and Plastics Processing Machinery and Technology (specialisation 215).

Links

Leave a comment